Both conventional breeding and genetic modification are methods for intentional manipulation of an organism’s heritable traits. To illustrate the differences, we take the example of producing drought-resistant corn.
To make an originally susceptible corn variety resistant to drought, conventional breeders can cross the susceptible corn variety with its resistant wild cousin. Offsprings exhibiting drought-resistance (i.e. the desired quality) are then selected and crossed with its resistant parent (backcrossing). The offsprings are subjected to several more generations of backcrossing and selection before a new variety of corn stably exhibiting drought-resistance can be achieved.
As conventional breeding involves the transfer of many thousands of genes randomly, the outcomes are often difficult to predict and it typically takes many years before an organism with the desired characteristics can be produced. Conventional breeding is also dependent on genetic compatibility of donor and recipient organisms. Breeders may not be able to cross distantly-related species, or the resultant offsprings may not be viable.
Genetic modification, on the other hand, is a more precise method. As we can see from Diagram 1, it involves the identification, isolation, and introduction of specific gene(s) from donor to recipient organisms. Genetic modification also permits the transfer of genes between totally different organisms, for example from a turnip to a cereal grain or from a bacterium to corn. The first use of this was in the 1980s, where E.coli bacterium was genetically modified to carry human insulin gene. As a result of this technology, high quality insulin can now be produced cheaply for diabetic patients. |